Skip to main content Skip to search Skip to search

Philosophy Modern

Semantic Challenges to Realism

Dummett and Putnam

by (author) Mark Quentin Gardiner

Publisher
University of Toronto Press
Initial publish date
Aug 2000
Category
Modern, Criticism
  • Hardback

    ISBN
    9780802047717
    Publish Date
    Aug 2000
    List Price
    $139.00
  • eBook

    ISBN
    9781442679740
    Publish Date
    Jul 2000
    List Price
    $136.00

Classroom Resources

Where to buy it

Description

Anti-realism entered the philosophical scene some twenty years ago, and has since become a widely accepted view. But although many philosophers espouse anti-realism, the only sustained arguments for the position are due to Michael Dummett and Hilary Putnam. Much discussion of their views has appeared in the journals, especially concerning some of Putnam's pithy and memorable expositions, like the 'Brain in the Vat'; however, this is the first book to provide a thorough examination and rebuttal of their arguments.

Dummett's and Putnam's arguments are long, complex, and often technical. They have been developed over time, often in response to criticisms of earlier formulations or to the parallel but independent research of others, and accordingly, each of their premises gives rise to a host of issues, questions, and concerns. Mark Gardiner guides us through this difficult terrain, discussing the abundant literature on the subject along the way. With its compelling argument and accessible style, this thorough and authoritative study will provide an important contribution to the realism/anti-realism debate.

About the author

Mark Q. Gardiner is an instructor in the Department of Humanities, Mount Royal College, Calgary, Alberta.

Mark Quentin Gardiner's profile page